German Top Court Rules Hamburg Judge Wrongly Blocked Usmanov EU Lawsuit
Russia's Alischer Usmanov sued the EU Council in Germany; BGH finds a court president unlawfully overrode the presiding judge's order.
Germany's Federal Court of Justice, the Bundesgerichtshof, has ruled that the president of the Hamburg Regional Court acted unlawfully by blocking Russian billionaire Alischer Usmanov's lawsuit against the Council of the European Union, according to a statement released November 2, 2026.
The case centers on Usmanov's legal challenge against the EU Council, which has imposed sanctions against the oligarch. The Hamburg court president intervened to prevent the suit from proceeding before a German court, a move that the BGH has now determined violated proper judicial procedure by overriding the decision of the judge originally assigned to the case.
Read more US Resolves USMCA Labor Dispute at Mexican Food Facility →
Germany's Foreign Ministry had also sought to prevent the lawsuit from being heard in a German court, adding a diplomatic dimension to the procedural dispute. The BGH's ruling appears to separate executive-branch pressure from the judiciary's independent authority to manage its own docket and case assignments.
The decision raises broader questions about the extent to which sanctioned individuals may pursue legal remedies in European national courts against EU institutions, and whether foreign policy considerations can legitimately influence domestic judicial processes. Legal observers may watch closely to see how the case proceeds now that the procedural barrier has been struck down.
Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.
